Wikipedia:Good article reassessment/Irish Figure Skating Championships/1

* '''Keep.''' This is nothing but retaliatory BS. Nominator quick-failed my [[Talk:Brazilian Figure Skating Championships/GA1|Brazilian Figure Skating Championships]], and cited [[Irish Figure Skating Championships]] as an example of a what a comparable GA should look like. I stated that these two articles are structurally alike, so I didn't understand how one was GA and the other was not. His response: "I already explained it." And then suddenly this. So that was a pretty lickety-split 180. The reason I sent this (and Brazil) here instead of FL is because the competitions are relatively new. Compare that to, say, [[German Figure Skating Championships]], which has 125+ years worth of results, and are overwhelmingly lists. This is an article with a few lists. [[User:Bgsu98|'''Bgsu98''']] [[User talk:Bgsu98|(Talk)]] 22:55, 18 April 2026 (UTC)

* '''Keep.''' This is nothing but retaliatory BS. Nominator quick-failed my [[Talk:Brazilian Figure Skating Championships/GA1|Brazilian Figure Skating Championships]], and cited [[Irish Figure Skating Championships]] as an example of a what a comparable GA should look like. I stated that these two articles are structurally alike, so I didn't understand how one was GA and the other was not. His response: "I already explained it." And then suddenly this. So that was a pretty lickety-split 180. The reason I sent this (and Brazil) here instead of FL is because the competitions are relatively new. Compare that to, say, [[German Figure Skating Championships]], which has 125+ years worth of results, and are overwhelmingly lists. This is an article with a few lists. [[User:Bgsu98|'''Bgsu98''']] [[User talk:Bgsu98|(Talk)]] 22:55, 18 April 2026 (UTC)

*:Before today I didn't know you or interacted with you. This is hardly "retaliatory BULLSHIT".

*:And, [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Brazilian_Figure_Skating_Championships/GA1&oldid=1349760311 yes, I explaned it]: "The article has an introduction and then proceeds to include 3 tables, with no additional text. Therefore, it qualifies as a list [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Brazilian_Figure_Skating_Championships&oldid=1349756465 as it is currently written.]" An acceptable failure based on [[WP:GA?]]. I selected [[Irish Figure Skating Championships]] as it was another skating championship in the category. Once I read it, it was clear it doesn't meet the criteria either.

*:"The reason I sent this (and Brazil) here instead of FL is because the competitions are relatively new." is enough to support what I said above: "It is similar to many of the lists listed at Category:FL-Class Figure skating articles". being "relatively new" is not a reason to send lists to GA instead of FL. [[User:Tbhotch|Tbhotch]]^{[[User talk:Tbhotch|™]]} (CC BY-SA 4.0) 23:09, 18 April 2026 (UTC)