Talk:Women's Image Network Awards

Talk:Women's Image Network Awards

Circular references, no primary sources: new section

← Previous revision Revision as of 01:30, 23 April 2026
Line 11: Line 11:


I tagged this article for cleanup, in particular, the yearly ceremony section. The awards are approaching their 25th year, and each one mentioned here is too long for navigation. They all need to be in table form, as the latter ones are, and/or only have the winners listed. — '''[[User:CAWylie|Wylie]][[User talk:CAWylie|pedia]]''' 10:33, 5 February 2017 (UTC)
I tagged this article for cleanup, in particular, the yearly ceremony section. The awards are approaching their 25th year, and each one mentioned here is too long for navigation. They all need to be in table form, as the latter ones are, and/or only have the winners listed. — '''[[User:CAWylie|Wylie]][[User talk:CAWylie|pedia]]''' 10:33, 5 February 2017 (UTC)

== Circular references, no primary sources ==

The WIN Awards official website (thewinawards.com) links its archives page directly back to this Wikipedia article, creating a circular reference. Winners lists in this article are largely unsourced and independent press coverage of the ceremony appears minimal. I can find no published lists of winners anywhere. Archive sources are returning no results for this award and, again, references often refer back to this article, creating a circular reference with no primary source. Editors should seek primary sources such as Wayback Machine snapshots of thewinawards.com prior to the circular link being established. Note that even Wayback Machine snapshots of thewinawards.com would constitute a self-published primary source and would not meet Wikipedia's reliable source requirements. What is needed is independent third-party coverage — a trade publication, newspaper, or other reliable outlet reporting on the ceremony and its winners. Until such sources are found, the unsourced winners lists in this article may not meet Wikipedia's verifiability policy. [[User:Lexlex|Lexlex]] ([[User talk:Lexlex|talk]]) 01:30, 23 April 2026 (UTC)