Talk:Jewish Social Democratic Labour Party in Palestine (Poale Zion)
Merge into Poale Zion (Palestine section)
| ← Previous revision | Revision as of 20:56, 27 April 2026 | ||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
In most historical writing, Poale Zion activity in Palestine is presented as part of the **broader Poale Zion movement**, alongside branches in Russia, Poland, Britain, and elsewhere. The sources used here treat the Palestine organization as a territorial branch rather than as a separate party in its own right. |
In most historical writing, Poale Zion activity in Palestine is presented as part of the **broader Poale Zion movement**, alongside branches in Russia, Poland, Britain, and elsewhere. The sources used here treat the Palestine organization as a territorial branch rather than as a separate party in its own right. |
||
Much of the content—founding in 1906, ideology, leadership, and activity in Ottoman Palestine—is already covered, or would naturally fit, in the existing |
Much of the content—founding in 1906, ideology, leadership, and activity in Ottoman Palestine—is already covered, or would naturally fit, in the existing Palestine‑related sections of [[Poale Zion]]. Keeping a separate article risks unnecessary duplication and fragmentation, contrary to the approach outlined in [[WP:SUMMARYSTYLE]] and [[WP:CFORK]]. |
||
Per [[WP:MERGE]], a better solution would be to merge the sourced content into a clearly labeled subsection such as **“Palestine / Ottoman Palestine”** within [[Poale Zion]], while retaining any unique, reliably sourced details rather than removing them. |
Per [[WP:MERGE]], a better solution would be to merge the sourced content into a clearly labeled subsection such as **“Palestine / Ottoman Palestine”** within [[Poale Zion]], while retaining any unique, reliably sourced details rather than removing them. |
||
