Talk:Berberism
POV tag: Reply
| ← Previous revision | Revision as of 03:24, 24 April 2026 | ||
| Line 93: | Line 93: | ||
:Berberism is also not one singular all encompassing ideology. The '''[[Riffian independence movement|Riffian Independence Movement]]''' for example is not [[Anti-Arab racism|Anti- Arab]], and venerates [[Abd el-Krim]] (an anti-colonial leader and islamic judge). Practically the complete opposite of what the lead of the article would suggest Berberism is. Yet most definitely is considered a Berberist movement. That disparity has to be accounted for. [[User:Imteghren|Imteghren]] ([[User talk:Imteghren|talk]]) 15:36, 30 March 2026 (UTC) |
:Berberism is also not one singular all encompassing ideology. The '''[[Riffian independence movement|Riffian Independence Movement]]''' for example is not [[Anti-Arab racism|Anti- Arab]], and venerates [[Abd el-Krim]] (an anti-colonial leader and islamic judge). Practically the complete opposite of what the lead of the article would suggest Berberism is. Yet most definitely is considered a Berberist movement. That disparity has to be accounted for. [[User:Imteghren|Imteghren]] ([[User talk:Imteghren|talk]]) 15:36, 30 March 2026 (UTC) |
||
:{{Agree}} with a POV tag on all three articles. [[User:NAADAAN|NAADAAN]] ([[User talk:NAADAAN|talk]]) 23:59, 31 March 2026 (UTC) |
:{{Agree}} with a POV tag on all three articles. [[User:NAADAAN|NAADAAN]] ([[User talk:NAADAAN|talk]]) 23:59, 31 March 2026 (UTC) |
||
:@[[User:Allan Nonymous|Allan Nonymous]] The changes you've made look good. Some other stuff I noticed (not expecting you to deal with these, just pointing them out): |
|||
:1. The article barely gives Berberists any agency, it mostly talks about how they reacted to colonialism or Arabization instead of how they were active players with their own ideas and goals. |
|||
:2. The article is disproportionally focused on the history of French colonialism (Kabyle myth, Franco-Berber schools, Berber Dahir), which results in Berberism being portrayed as a colonial invention. |
|||
:3. The Morocco section treats the [[Years of Lead (Morocco)|Years of Lead]] like a footnote mentioning it only in passing before going into details of civil liberties granted afterwards. [[User:Lankdadank|lankdadank]] ([[User talk:Lankdadank|chat]]) 03:24, 24 April 2026 (UTC) |
|||
